Most Related Products Get Ignored. Here's the Simple Fix

You’ve probably noticed it: a customer adds something to their cart, and your website helpfully suggests five other products they might like. But they scroll past without a glance. Then they hit checkout, and your average order value stays exactly where it was.

Here’s the frustrating part—that “related products” section exists for a reason. It’s genuinely supposed to help increase average order value and boost your ecommerce conversion rate. The problem isn’t that the idea doesn’t work. The problem is that most online stores are showing customers products they have zero reason to care about.

Let me explain what’s actually happening, and then show you the one change that turns this around.

The Problem Nobody Talks About

When you browse an online store, you see a “Customers also bought” or “You might like” section. It feels helpful. It looks professional. But there’s often a disconnect between what you came to buy and what gets recommended.

Imagine walking into a bookstore, finding a cookbook, and having the staff recommend a pile of completely unrelated books—fiction, history, a book about fly fishing. Some of those books might be great. But they have nothing to do with why you’re standing there holding a cookbook.

That’s what happens on most ecommerce sites. The related products section pulls from a default algorithm (basically an automatic system that matches items in a way that sometimes makes sense and sometimes doesn’t). The store owner might use the default settings on their platform, or they let an automated recommendation system run on autopilot. Nobody actually stops to ask: Will the person buying this item actually want to buy that other item?

The result? Customers ignore the section entirely. Your cross-selling strategy becomes invisible.

Why Context Actually Matters

Here’s what changes everything: matching products based on what the customer is actually trying to do right now.

Let’s say someone just clicked on a winter coat. What do they probably want to see next? Not random items from your store. They want:

  • Scarves, gloves, or hats (things that go with winter coats)
  • Other coats in different colors or styles (because they’re thinking about outerwear)
  • Maybe accessories specifically designed for cold weather

They do not want to see a summer sundress, even if that sundress is your bestseller.

When your product recommendations section shows items that actually belong in the same world as what the customer is looking at, something magic happens. It doesn’t feel like sales pressure. It feels helpful. And helpful recommendations get clicked.

This is the core of a smart cross-selling strategy: showing products that are genuinely related to what the customer is already interested in.

The One Change That Works

Here’s the practical fix, and it doesn’t require overhauling your website or bringing in a developer.

Instead of letting your platform’s default related products section run on autopilot, manually curate it.

For each product on your site, take two minutes to ask yourself: What would someone buying this actually want next? Then select those specific products to show in the “related products” area.

Let’s walk through a real example. Say you sell home office supplies. You have a listing for an ergonomic desk chair. Your current related products section might show:

  • A desk lamp (makes sense—office setup)
  • A desk organizer (makes sense—office desk)
  • Printer paper (generic office supply—probably not)
  • A webcam (okay, but not everyone at a desk needs one)
  • A filing cabinet (makes sense)

Compare that to a manually curated list:

  • A standing desk converter (someone buying a nice chair is thinking about their whole setup)
  • A desk pad or mouse pad (protects the desk and goes with the chair)
  • A lumbar pillow (complements the ergonomic theme)
  • Other chair styles from your inventory (person is definitely shopping for seating)

Notice the difference? The second list is made up of things a real person buying an ergonomic chair would actually consider purchasing. They’re not random items with loose connections. They’re thoughtful products that complete a purchase intent.

How This Lifts Your Average Order Value

When product recommendations actually make sense, three things happen:

First, people actually look at them. If the suggestions feel random or irrelevant, customers scroll right past. When they’re contextual and useful, they get attention.

Second, the purchase rate goes up. In retail, this is called conversion—when a browser becomes a buyer. Smart recommendations don’t just get looked at; they get bought. A customer who was planning to spend forty dollars on a chair might add a lumbar pillow for another thirty. That’s a 75% increase in average order value on one purchase.

Third, it compounds over time. Every time someone adds one of your suggested products to their cart, your average order value inches higher. Do this across hundreds or thousands of orders, and you’re talking about real revenue growth without needing to drive more traffic or increase your marketing spend.

The Honest Limitation

Here’s what I’m not going to promise: this isn’t a magical button that triples your sales overnight.

But it is one of the highest-impact, lowest-effort changes you can make. You’re not redesigning your site. You’re not installing complicated software. You’re thinking like a customer and showing them products that actually matter to them.

The work is minimal. The payoff is real and measurable.

Getting Started Today

Pick three or four of your most-viewed products. For each one, spend a few minutes thinking about what someone buying that item would naturally want next. Then manually set your related products section to show those items instead of whatever the default algorithm picked.

Watch what happens to your average order value over the next two weeks.

You’ll probably be surprised at how many customers actually click on recommendations that actually make sense. And once you see that working, you can expand it across your whole catalog at whatever pace makes sense for your business.

That’s it. That’s the change. No technical knowledge required—just a little thinking about what your customers actually want.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *